Black Manhattan Recipe 2025
Black Manhattan Recipe – A Bold Twist on a Classic Cocktail
If you’re a fan of the traditional Manhattan but fancy something richer and more complex, the Black Manhattan recipe is exactly what you need. Swapping out sweet vermouth for Amaro, this cocktail brings a deeper, more herbal flavour that’s perfect for evening sipping.
In this guide from Easy Pie Recipes, we’ll show you how to make the perfect Black Manhattan, including ingredients, instructions, garnish ideas, and tips to elevate your home bar game.
What is a Black Manhattan?
The Black Manhattan is a modern take on the classic Manhattan cocktail. Originally created in 2005 by bartender Todd Smith in San Francisco, this version replaces sweet vermouth with Amaro, an Italian herbal liqueur, for a bolder, bittersweet profile.
With rich flavours of spice, herbs, and a touch of sweetness, the Black Manhattan is ideal for those who love strong, stirred drinks with a twist.
Classic Black Manhattan Recipe
🍸 Ingredients:
- 60ml Rye whiskey (or Bourbon for a slightly sweeter touch)
- 30ml Amaro Averna (or another dark Amaro like Montenegro or Cynar)
- 1–2 dashes of Angostura bitters
- 1–2 dashes of orange bitters
- Ice
- Luxardo cherry or orange peel, for garnish
📝 Instructions:
- Chill your glass – Pop a coupe or lowball glass in the freezer while you mix.
- Stir the ingredients – In a mixing glass filled with ice, combine rye whiskey, Amaro, and bitters.
- Mix well – Stir gently for about 30 seconds until chilled.
- Strain and serve – Strain into your chilled glass.
- Garnish – Top with a Luxardo cherry or a twist of orange peel for a fragrant finish.
Ingredient Notes
- Amaro Averna is the most common choice for a traditional Black Manhattan. It has a balanced bitterness and caramel notes.
- Rye whiskey gives the drink a spicier edge, while bourbon adds a touch of sweetness — choose based on your preference.
- Using quality ice and stirring (not shaking) preserves clarity and mouthfeel.
Variations to Try
- Smoky Black Manhattan: Use a smoky whiskey like Laphroaig or a splash of Islay Scotch.
- Black Walnut Manhattan: Add a dash of black walnut bitters for a nutty depth.
- Coffee Manhattan: Use Amaro with coffee notes, like Amaro Lucano or Jägermeister.
When to Serve a Black Manhattan
This cocktail is perfect for:
- Dinner parties
- Cold winter nights
- After-dinner sipping
- Impressing guests with your cocktail skills
It’s also a wonderful alternative for Negroni or Old Fashioned fans looking for something a little different.
More Cocktail Recipes from Easy Pie Recipes
Looking to expand your mixology skills? Check out these cocktail favourites:
- Classic Manhattan Recipe – The Original Sip of Sophistication
- Whiskey Sour Recipe – Smooth and Citrusy
- Espresso Martini Recipe – Bold and Energising
Final Sip
The Black Manhattan recipe is bold, elegant, and deeply satisfying — the perfect blend of old-world tradition and modern cocktail craft. It’s a must-try for whiskey lovers and those looking to elevate their home bartending.
Conclusion
The Black Manhattan recipe offers a sophisticated and modern twist on a timeless classic. With its rich blend of rye whiskey and herbal Amaro, it’s the ideal cocktail for those who enjoy bold, complex flavours. Whether you’re hosting a dinner party or simply unwinding after a long day, the Black Manhattan delivers elegance in every sip. Try it for yourself and discover why this cocktail has become a favourite among discerning drinkers.
Cheers to crafting unforgettable drinks at home – one glass at a time.
🍸 Ready to make your own? Give this recipe a try and share your creation on social media with #EasyPieCocktails.
